Daily Archives: June 25, 2012

Late try from Rob Harley helps Scotland edge out Samoa

Scotland‘s Greig Laidlaw converted a try by debuting flanker Rob Harley a minute from fulltime to give the visitors a 17-16 win over Samoa on Saturday and a clean sweep of matches on their southern hemisphere tour.

Samoa seemed headed for its first-ever win over Scotland when flyhalf Tusi Pisi, who provided all of his team’s points, scored a 61st minute try to give it a 16-10 lead.

Scotland, who had previously beaten Australia 9-6 and Fiji 37-25, applied continuous pressure but were denied by a tenacious defense until the last play of the game.

The Scots chose to tap and run a penalty near the Samoa goalline and replacement flyhalf Mike Blair ran wide before turning the ball back to Harley who scored near the posts, setting up Laidlaw’s winning conversion.

Scotland led 7-6 after a first half marked by the determined defense of both teams, forcing handling errors and breakdowns in continuity.

Pisi scored the first points of the match through a penalty in the 15th minute but Scotland hit back with a try to Joe Ansbro. Center Matt Scott made one of the rare line breaks in the first half and scrumhalf Chris Cusiter and winger Sean Lamont carried the move on before Ansbro ran onto the final pass.

Laidlaw converted from the sideline to give Scotland a 7-6 lead. Pisi added his second penalty in the 23rd to end the scoring in a physical first spell.

Samoa reclaimed the lead at 9-7 when Pisi added his third penalty early in the second half. Laidlaw quickly replied with a penalty in the 51st minute to make it 10-9 to Scotland.

Blair, who took the field as a 44th-minute replacement for Cusiter, began to test the Samoa defense with sniping runs from the base of rucks and Lamont and lock Richie Gray added pressure as determined ball-carriers.

Samoa broke through with their first try in the 61st minute. Scrumhalf Kahn Fotuali’i went on a long crossfield run looking for straight runners and picked up center Paul Williams who weaved infield and stepped through the tackle of Scotland winger Tim Visser.

Williams had support both outside and in and chose to go infield to Pisi who burst clear to score. Pisi converted his own try and Samoa led 16-10.

One of more than 15,000 ecstatic fans at Apia Stadium burst through a police cordon to embrace Pisi while wearing the lava-lava or traditional skirt.

More supporters ran on to mob winger Paul Perez when he seemed to have scored a decisive try 10 minutes later but Samoa was called back and awarded a lineout because a Scotland player had earlier put a foot in touch.

Samoa’s lead endured for almost 20 minutes, though Scotland set and reset a long series of scrums within five meters of the goalline in the last 10 minutes of the match. The Samoa defense fought desperately to hold back the Scots and seemed to have done so as fulltime approached, until a late error conceded the penalty from which Harley scored.

Editor’s Choice: VIDEO: Watch the best and worst penalties taken over the years

Jun 26 2012

BEST:

1. Zinedine Zidane

There is no bigger stage than the World Cup Final but in 2006, Zidane was the greatest player on the planet. His confidence was sky high and he proved it with an audacious spot-kick against Italy No.1 Gigi Buffon. His chip clipped the underside of the bar and bounced just inches in. Sheer class.

2. AnTONIN PANENKA

The Czechoslovakia midfielder showed the rest of the names on our list the way forward. In the 1976 Euro Championship Final against West Germany he was handed the chance to win the tournament with the last spot-kick in the shootout. In a stunning show of composure he let Sepp Maier dive to his left and then chipped the ball down the middle. Groundbreaking.

3. JOHAN CRUYFF

This penalty went down in history and is still unique today. In a Dutch league match against Telstar in 1982, Cruyff opted to pass the spot-kick to team-mate Jesper Olsen who returned the favour and Cruyff tapped the ball home from close range as their opponents simply looked on in disbelief.

4. ANDY WALKER

In a Scottish Cup tie against fierce rivals Kilmarnock in 1999, Ayr ace Walker had a huge weight on his shoulders when he stepped up to face Gordon Marshall. The hitman proved the coolest man on the park though and his delicate chip made him an instant hero with Somerset Park fans.

5. JIM McINTYRE

McIntyre must have known his spot-kick would be decisive in the 2007 Scottish Cup semi-final replay against Hibs. So to dink it past the keeper at Hampden took an enormous amount of bottle – but paid off for the Dunfermline striker as it sealed a crucial 1-0 win.

WORST:

1. AMIR SAYOUD

Only the Al Ahly striker will know what he was trying to do in September 2011 but his effort is a great reminder of why not to stutter a run-up. The Eyptian stalled just before the ball and then fell, earning himself a red face, a yellow card and a few million hits on YouTube.

2. DAVID BECKHAM

Even the world’s biggest stars can mess it up from 12 yards as Beckham, England’s master of the dead ball, found out at Euro 2004 in the quarter-final shootout against hosts Portugal. The midfielder could only look back at the spot in disgust after he blazed his effort high and wide. It proved yet another miserable shootout for the Three Lions, who crashed out.

3. THIERRY HENRY ROBERT PIRES

With the talent Henry and Pires had, this has to go down as their most embarrassing moment. The Arsenal duo tried to “do a Cruyff” in 2005 and pass the ball between each other before scoring. But it didn’t quite go to plan as the initial touch was too soft and the players were left just looking at each other.

4. JAY RODRIGUEZ

The Burnley striker once plied his trade on loan at Stirling Albion and his penalty last February against Nottingham Forest would have shamed even the Scottish Second Division. Rodriguez slipped at the crucial moment and his sliced effort ended up closer to the corner flag than the goal.

5. PETER DEVINE

Poor Peter. Lancaster City v Whitley Bay wouldn’t normally go down in history but Devine made sure of it in 1991 with one of the most humiliating penalties ever. He stumbled in the run-up and his “shot” trickled just two yards. Magic.

BT to roll out superfast broadband to 150000 homes

BroadbandBT said 338,000 Scottish homes and businesses already have access to superfast broadband

Superfast broadband will be made available to another 150,000 Scottish homes and businesses next year, BT has announced.

The investment is part of a £2.5bn roll-out of fibre broadband by BT across the UK.

The move will take the total number of homes and firms in Scotland who will have superfast broadband as an option to nearly one million.

BT said it would be “a massive shot in the arm” for local economies.

BT Scotland director Brendan Dick said: “Local firms and households who make the switch to fibre broadband will be able to do so much more with their connection, whether they’re using it for business, entertainment, education, social networking or shopping – or all of these at once.

“They’re joining more than 10 million premises now passed by our fibre network and becoming part of one of the fastest roll-outs of the technology anywhere in the world,” he added.

‘Modern world’

Infrastructure Secretary Alex Neil said communities across Scotland should have access to superfast broadband, no matter where they were based.

“Everyone recognises the importance of access to superfast broadband, not just for our local economies but for every aspect of life in the modern world,” he said.

BT’s local network business, Openreach, aims to make fibre broadband available to about two-thirds of UK homes and businesses by the end of 2014, using a mix of fibre to the cabinet (FTTC) and fibre to the premises (FTTP) technologies.

By spring 2013, the firm aims to make speeds of 330Mbps commercially available in any area where fibre broadband has been deployed.

The UK’s current average broadband speed is 7.6Mbps, according to regulator Ofcom.

On Monday, the Scottish government announced it would spend £120m to bring superfast broadband to communities in the Highlands and Islands.

Public agency Highlands and Islands Enterprise (HIE) is in discussions with BT about delivering the upgrade.

The programme of works will include laying underground and sub-sea cables.

The spending forms part of the Scottish government’s Scotland’s Digital Future: Infrastructure Action Plan.

Locations included in BT’s roll-out in 2013

Inverurie

Peterhead

Brechin

Oban

Edinburgh Maybury

Stranraer

Cumnock

Stewarton

Dunbar

Glasgow Cranhill

Glasgow Shettleston

Irvine

Kilsyth

Wishaw

Glasgow Thornly Park

Prestwick

Blantyre

Carluke

Uddingston

Alexandria

Armadale

Aberdeenshire

Aberdeenshire

Angus

Argyll and Bute

City of Edinburgh

Dumfries and Galloway

East Ayrshire

East Ayrshire

East Lothian

Glasgow City

Glasgow City

North Ayrshire

North Lanarkshire

North Lanarkshire

Renfrewshire

South Ayrshire

South Lanarkshire

South Lanarkshire

South Lanarkshire

West Dunbartonshire

West Lothian

A more entrepreneurial Scotland ‘is hampered by lack of ambition’

By SCOTT REID

Published on Tuesday 26 June 2012 00:00

Scotland needs to raise its game when it comes to entrepreneurship, the country’s highest-profile businessman said yesterday, despite news of a jump in the number of people looking to become self-employed.

Sir Tom Hunter claimed a “lack of ambition” was undermining the nation’s success on the world stage and warned that standing still could prove costly.

His remarks came as research revealed the number of Scots expecting to start their own business in the next three years was significantly higher last year than in 2010.

The latest Global Entrepreneurship Monitor (GEM) found that the proportion of working age individuals on the brink of going it alone had leapt from 6 per cent to almost 10 per cent.

The report noted that a “long slow decline” in early-stage entrepreneurial activity had been arrested in 2011.

The monitor was compiled by Professor Jonathan Levie of Strathclyde University’s Hunter Centre for Entrepreneurship. Hunter – credited as Scotland’s first home-grown billionaire – donated £5m to establish the centre in 2000.

Levie said: “It is encouraging that entrepreneurial intention has increased and this could lead to an increase in actual new business creation rates.

“The long, slow decline in early-stage entrepreneurial activity also appears to have been arrested, if not reversed, in 2011.

“However, while there is room for optimism, more needs to be done to turn the intention to start a business into reality. Scottish entrepreneurs still face challenges in getting funding, customers and staff.

“There is also considerable scepticism across the Scottish public about the wisdom of embarking on an entrepreneurial career, despite the relatively high status afforded to successful entrepreneurs,” added Levie, who also co-directs the UK-wide GEM programme.

Access to finance continues to be one of the key barriers to launching a business, with half of non-entrepreneurs thinking it would be their biggest hurdle and almost half of those in business citing it as their biggest difficulty.

The survey also revealed that the proportion of staff in small businesses engaged in new business activity for their employer is significantly lower in Scotland than in the UK as a whole – despite high levels of recognition by employees that their companies provided support to those who came up with ideas.

Hunter said: “The report shows that the proportion of working-age individuals who intend to start a business has also increased, but if we are to succeed on a global stage, we need to do more.

“In many areas we are no longer lagging behind the rest of the UK. Perhaps some of our initiatives in education are now starting to bear fruit, as founders’ knowledge of how to start in business in Scotland compares favourably to the UK.

“Now we need ambition that avoids or jumps the hurdles, innovation that doesn’t expect government to provide, or you or me to solve problems. We need entrepreneurs that get on with it.”

Colin Borland of the Federation of Small Businesses in Scotland said: “There still seems to be a significant gap between the public’s view of what it takes to run a business and the reality. This has to be addressed.”

Finance secretary John Swinney said: “The findings of this report are hugely encouraging and show increasing rates of entrepreneurialism and business start-ups, which are key to our aim of building a stronger and more prosperous Scotland.”


  • Email to a friend
  • Print this page


Comments

There are 1 comments to this article

“Sir Tom Hunter claimed a “lack of ambition” was undermining the nation’s success on the world stage and warned that standing still could prove costly.” I agree. Voting NO in the referendum will be Scotland not just standing still but going into a coma. Vote YES to independence Mr Hunter.


Your view

Please

Scotland looks to Canada for help drafting referendum on independence

As Scotland prepares for a historic referendum on independence within the next two years, opposition leaders are urging Edinburgh to enlist a Canadian elections expert to help frame a fair question when Scotland‘s 5.2 million people are asked whether they want to divide the 305-year-old United Kingdom.

Ron Gould, who retired as deputy chief of Elections Canada in 2001, gained widespread acclaim in Scotland for his damning report on the botched 2007 Scottish election, when voting complications spoiled the ballots of more than 140,000 citizens.

Now, the leaders of Scotland‘s Labour, Conservative and Liberal Democrat parties have sent a joint letter to First Minister Alex Salmond — head of the governing, pro-independence Scottish National Party — urging him to appoint “an eminent academic of similar standing to Prof. Ron Gould” to lead the referendum process.

“The substantial issue is the wording of the referendum question and we very much hope to have a constructive discussion on producing a form of words that the people of Scotland can have confidence in,” states the letter to Salmond, signed by Labour party leader Johann Lamont, Conservative leader Ruth Davidson and Willie Rennie of the Liberal Democrats. “We are sure you agree that ensuring that the public have the utmost confidence in the fairness of this referendum is paramount.”

The opposition leaders have also indicated plans to “sound out” Gould himself for the job, adding a new twist to a referendum battle that officially began Monday with the launch of a pro-unionist campaign led by Edinburgh Labour MP Alistair Darling, Britain’s former chancellor of the exchequer.

Reached at his home in Ottawa on Monday, the 78-year-old Gould told Postmedia News he “would be flattered” if asked to play a role in shaping the referendum question and “I’d certainly give it serious consideration.”

He added, though, that, “I’d have to balance this against the fact that this is a Scottish election and involves the United Kingdom and England, and there is an electoral commission.

“They’ve got the talent, they’ve got the expertise there. I really don’t know why they would need me other than the fact that I would be standing outside looking in.”

In fact, it was Gould’s scrupulously objective, outside perspective that drew general applause for his report on the 2007 Scottish election, a fiasco he concluded was caused principally by a complicated ballot that combined voting for local councils with choices for Scotland‘s parliament. But he also criticized rushed and ill-conceived late changes to the voting process, undue interference by political parties in the electoral system and a general failure to put the needs of voters — including the design of a user-friendly ballot — ahead of all other competing interests.

The framing of the Scottish referendum question is a highly contentious issue, as it was in Canada before and after the narrow defeat of the Yes side in the 1995 sovereignty referendum in Quebec. British politicians have been debating whether to pass a “Clarity Act” similar to the one controversially adopted by the Canadian government in the years following the bitterly contested 1995 vote in Quebec.

Salmond has proposed different possibilities for the Scottish referendum at different times, including a single question — “Do you agree that Scotland should be an independent country?” — that some critics have panned because it makes no direct reference to the “negative” result that a Yes vote would also entail: breaking apart the United Kingdom.

Independence advocates also have drawn opposition fire for proposing a two-question referendum that would seek voters’ opinions on both Scottish independence and on a still-united but more devolved relationship between Holyrood — the Scottish legislature formed in 1999 — and the U.K. parliament at Westminster, giving Scotland greater control over its affairs.

In April, Gould told the BBC that a two-question ballot on Scotland‘s future would “muddy the waters” and potentially trigger a fierce, post-referendum debate over the meaning of the results.

“The last thing you want to do is to end up with a referendum where there is conflict as to whether that referendum was truly the expression of the will of the Scottish people,” he told the BBC at the time. “One question, suitably tested and unambiguous, can do this — assuming that you, ahead of time, determine what constitutes a clear majority . . . Two questions will muddy the waters, in my opinion.”

Gould told Postmedia News on Monday that asking two questions on a Scottish referendum ballot would be “complicating the situation and raising new questions” about Scotland‘s political future.

“In my view, the ideal is to go with one specific question,” he added. “Given the fact that this is a major, major issue, why not deal with the key issue of independence first? Then, if that’s not the case, look at further devolution as a second option.”

Gould, who likened discussing the issue to “walking on eggshells,” ventured the further observation that, “if the first question (on independence) is rejected but it’s very, very close, obviously the Scottish government will have more leverage to negotiate devolution without having a second question.”

He also called it “critical” to have a “unanimous decision” — long before ballots are cast in any referendum — “about what constitutes a satisfactory majority — keeping in mind the voter turnout. If you get 50-per-cent plus one with a 40-per-cent voter turnout, is that going to have the same acceptance level as if you have a 60-per-cent voter turnout?”

Drawing on Canada’s experience, Gould noted that the passage of the Clarity Act — championed by former Liberal prime minister Jean Chretien and his intergovernmental affairs minister Stephane Dion — only happened after the No side’s razor-thin victory in 1995 on a highly disputed question.

“Keep in mind that the Clarity Act was an after-the-fact piece of legislation,” said Gould, an Order of Canada recipient who has served as a consultant or expert observer in scores of national elections around the world, including landmark votes in Bosnia and South Africa. “Certainly, the last thing you want to do (in Scotland) is get into that challenge.”

Gould said the 2014 target date for the Scottish referendum is approaching fast and demands prompt resolution of all issues surrounding question design and the interpretation of results prior to “technical testing” and other preparatory work.

“All of these advance decisions and agreements are really critical,” said Gould, “and need time to be worked out.”

It’s Scotland’s top coach v Scotland’s top player…

Du Coudray, a South African, has assisted Davydenko on an ad hoc basis ever since they met at a tournament in Poland in 2006. “I did a training block with him in December, but more often it’s just about meeting him on tour and talking through technical issues,” Du Coudray said. “He’s a very good athlete and moves incredibly well. He has an undimmed desire to be a better player and has a great work ethic.”

Davydenko, a former world No 3 who won the Barclays ATP World Tour Finals when the event was first staged at London’s O2 Arena three years ago, has struggled with his fitness in recent years and is now No 47 in the world rankings. However, the 31-year-old Russian, who is quick around the court and makes up for his lack of power by striking the ball exceptionally early, has beaten Murray (pictured) four times in their nine career meetings.

“These guys play each other so much that the process is not about coming up with an innovative strategy, it’s about reinforcing what Nikolay does well and minimising his failings,” Du Coudray said. “If Nikolay plays well then Andy will have to worry about him. If Andy plays well, then it’s Nikolay who will have to worry.”

Du Coudray said that Murray’s example was an inspiration for the young Scots he coaches. “Andy has simply and effectively provided a lot of motivation,” he said. “There are a lot of promising young tennis players in Scotland. I believe there are Scots who will make tennis their professional career, and then there is another generation coming through on the back of it.”

Murray, who has reached the semi-finals here for the last three years, could face some major tests in subsequent rounds against big servers, but said he would be “stupid” to look beyond Davydenko. “I won’t be making that mistake,” he said. “He was in the top four or five players for a number years. He’s won some big events. He’s won the Tour Finals. He’s won Masters Series. It’s going to be a tough match. He hasn’t played so well this year, but he has a lot of experience.”

Scottish News: Anti-mafia team to target gangsters running business through taxi companies and other firms

Jun 26 2012
by Paul OHare

Police large

POLICE want “anti-mafia” agents to control licenses for taxis, nurseries and security firms to stop criminal gangs running legitimate businesses.

It would mean powers being transferred from councils to specialist teams.

The Scottish Crime and Drug Enforcement Agency are examining how countries such as Italy and Holland stop gangsters gaining a foothold in lucrative industries.

Up to £9billion of public money is spent on buying everything from pencils to hospitals in Scotland every year.

Gaining a foothold in that business allows crooks to both clean and conceal their dirty cash.

In recent years, criminals have diversified from pubs and security firms to tanning parlours, nail bars, care homes and nurseries.

SCDEA director general Gordon Meldrum said: “If criminals can get their hands on a public sector contract, it will provide them with a regular monthly income.

“It stabilises an otherwise chaotic business operating model. It gives them the confidence to fund the next drugs, firearms or human trafficking operation.

“That’s why it is so important for us to work with central and local government and the private sector to make sure they don’t get any big Scottish contracts.”

Detective Chief Inspector Ronnie Megaughin, the SCDEA’s head of interventions, said it was difficult to accept how some companies with links to crime were granted licences by local authorities.

Lessons could be learned from some of our European neighbours.

Mr Megaughin said: “Italy is subject to the same procurement rules as the UK but they have domestic law which allows them in certain sectors to compel people to obtain anti-Mafia certification.

“We are looking at the potential for that here. In Italy, the director and others need to swear an oath to say they are not subject to any anti-Mafia measures, including police investigations.

“They have to satisfy a government official of their integrity. In Holland, rather than have local authorities making decisions on licensing, vetted civil servants do it.”

Global anti-corruption body Transparency International say the UK has a very low level of corruption.

But Mr Megaughin added: “Organised crime has been with us for centuries. It has changed and adapted to maximise profits.

“We need to change, too.”

He claimed the Security Industry Authority had been successful in cracking down on the industry. He added: “It has had a long-standing issue around intimidation.

“What we are trying to do is divorce the decision from where security will be provided.

“A supermarket will obviously have a board to make decisions. What we want is a decision by them that they will only use accredited security.

“We also need to have a healthy debate about whether police intelligence should play a bigger part within these decisions.”

Labour MSP and former SCDEA director general Graeme Pearson welcomed the plans.

He said: “It is worth examining to find out how we better protect the entire public licensing system.

“Quite obviously, organised crime have managed, through what they call clean skins, to protect themselves from law enforcement.

“It is always going to be very difficult for some people in public life to deal with these groups.

“If you are fairly low down the pecking order and you are trying to administer licensing, it can be very difficult.”

Pearson said people in every community knew organised crime figures who seemed to be above the law.

He added: “They are still making money and I wouldn’t imagine they would be affected too much by the economic downturn.”

How criminals move into business

TAXI FIRMS

RUSSELL STIRTON

In January, two crooked businessmen were ordered to hand over almost £1million after losing the longest dirty money court case in Scottish legal history.

The judge branded Russell Stirton, 51, and Alexander Anderson, 54, ruthless criminals who were guilty of drug dealing, gun running and extortion. Money was laundered through Stirton’s petrol station in Springburn, Glasgow.

NETWORK PRIVATE HIRE

A £2MILLION NHS taxi contract to take patients to hospital in Glasgow was awarded to Network Private Hire despite police fears over their alleged criminal links.

STEVIE MALCOLM

A SUPER-RICH businessman linked to crime bosses is in the running for a big airport taxi contract.

Stevie Malcolm, 48, dubbed the Fat Controller, is a director of Paisley Cab Company and ex-wife Julie Malcolm ran Barrhead’s Compass Cabs.

NURSERIES

POLICE raided the Rainforest Adventure Centre and Nursery in Motherwell two years ago in a money laundering probe.

SCDEA officers also swooped on the former home of Lindsay Nixon, boss of the nursery.

SECURITY FIRMS

SECURITY boss Bobby “The Devil” Dempster was accused of being a crime boss and had his licence suspended by the Security Industry Authority.

But they were forced into a climbdown when a sheriff blasted the lack of evidence against Dempster, 63.

His firm won a contract worth £162,000 to guard a rail link between Airdrie and Bathgate.

Scottish News: Germany boss Joachim Low says listening to Amy Macdonald helps him relax between games

Jun 26 2012
by Ben Archibald

AMY Macdonald has been revealed as the secret to Germany’s successful charge to the Euro 2012 semi-finals.

Amy Macdonald teaser

Team manager Joachim Loew listens to her songs between matches and says they help him cope with the stress of the tournament.

Scottish singer Amy is a massive star in Germany, whose football side breezed through the Euro 2012 group stages with three victories and defeated Greece 4-2 in Friday’s quarter-final.

Loew, 52, told German reporters: “I like listeningto music to relax away from the games.

“I particularly like the singer, Amy Macdonald. I’ve been listening to her a lot between games.

“She’s good.”

This Is The Life star Amy revealed at the weekend that she has split up with her fiance, footballer Steve Lovell.

The singer, from Bishopbriggs, near Glasgow, was performing at a festival in Germany. Amy, 24, is a big football fan and supports Rangers but has posted pics of herself in a Germany strip online in the past.

After Loew revealed he is a fan, she wrote on her Twitter site: “Joachim Loew, the Germany manager, was asked how he relaxes before the big games and he said that he listens to Amy Macdonald :-) awesome!”

And after Germany secured their victory over Greece to set up a semi-final clash with Italy, she joked: “Listening to me definitely worked for Germany ;-) .”

Amy parted with former Aberdeen striker Lovell a few weeks ago. She said: “We’re not together any more, so I am definitely not going toget married.”

Asked if there was a new man in her life, she said: “Definitely not, I’m concentrating on my music.”

Editor’s Choice: Two women reveal whether it’s OK for older females to date One Direction star Harry Styles

Jun 25 2012

Polly Hudson: No

Harry Styles is, unarguably, attractive.

If you’re a teen or a tween, fancying him is fine, normal and probably quite healthy.

If you’re a woman in your 30s, fancying him is a bit sad, but mostly just harmless fun.

But if you’re a woman in your 30s who not only fancies Harry but actually acts on it, it’s not only sick and wrong, it’s also completely baffling.

I seriously do not understand what Lucy Horobin and Caroline Flack were thinking, or how they managed to go through with it.

They can’t even blame alcohol for their terrible judgment, because at the time they both slept with him, Harry wasn’t old enough to buy any.

Maybe I am just a prude. But I never sleep with anyone I’m old enough to have given birth to.

An adult woman doing the horizontal mambo with a 17-year-old boy is just too icky for words.

I don’t believe Lucy when she says Harry “knew what he was doing in the bedroom” for one second… which is probably double the time their “liaison” lasted.

And, once it was over, can you imagine the agony of them trying to have a conversation?

It’s a well-known fact that men mature much more slowly than women, so a boy of 17 is probably as mature as a 14-year-old girl. He is still a child.

Even if you could bear the awkward fumbling and the juvenile chatter, surely even the most body-confident 30-something woman is going to think twice when she realises the last person her new lover saw naked was probably a teenage girl, which is who he’ll be comparing you to.

And I can only conclude Lucy and Caroline didn’t allow themselves to speculate about what mother issues Harry has, seeing as he seems to prefer sleeping with women old enough to be his.

Or why they can’t make things work with a man of their own age, who they have things in common with.

If they had thought about any of that, they surely couldn’t have gone through with it.

I’m not saying no woman should ever get involved with a younger man.

Younger men are fine. What’s not fine is a mature woman sleeping with a boy, which is what Harry is.

He wasn’t old enough to drink, or vote, or watch an 18-certificate film, so how is he old enough to have sex with?

This whole yucky business can be summed up by one fact – if we were talking about a
man in his 30s sleeping with a 17-year-old girl, no one would be giggling about it.

Charlotte Ward: Yes

harry styles one direction Image 3

It doesn’t surprise me one bit that teenage ladykiller Harry Styles was able to work his magic on 32-year-old DJ Lucy Horobin.

I never thought I’d end up a “cougar”, but at age 31 my serious five-year relationship ended and I found myself back on the singles market.

Suddenly, it seemed like all the men my own age were married or in long-term relationships. Yet when guys in their 20s asked me out, I was hesitant. Surely that was far too young?

But then the day after my 32nd birthday celebrations, I awoke to a text from a guy I’d met the night before, who, after several cocktails, I’d given my phone number too.

In the sober light of day, I was unsure. I estimated he was about 25 and too young but when he asked me on a date, I figured it couldn’t hurt.

We were a couple of hours into our date when he asked me how old I was.

When I revealed I was 32, he looked surprised. Then it was my turn to looked horrified – he admitted he was only 21.

“Does it really matter?” he asked. “I don’t have a problem with it.”

Although I had my reservations, I kept seeing him. After feeling weighed down by the end of my long-term relationship, I found that being with a younger man was fun.

I loved the fact that there were no serious, intense discussions.

Instead, we spent carefree days holding hands in the park or evenings out dancing. My new boyfriend was also the perfect gentleman, refusing to let me pay for a thing on our dates, carrying my bags and always opening doors.

He talked with enthusiasm about his ambitions and dreams and his energy was infectious.

Maybe it was this same unbridled lust for life that attracted Lucy to Harry when she was on a break from her marriage.

The fact is, being a single woman in your 30s is hard. Often it feels like a no-win situation. Everyone says you should be settling down before your eggs shrivel and then guys in their 30s avoid you because they assume you’ll drag them on to the “desperation express” – destination marriage and babies.

Since my first toyboy romance, I’ve dated several guys in their early 20s and generally I find them to be charming, keen and fun.

Last year at the age of 33, I dated a guy who was 22 and who would constantly tell me how much he enjoyed my company.

“I like that you have plenty to say and that you don’t get jealous or bitch like younger girls I’ve dated,” he said.

But it is true age-gap relationships can have a short shelf life.

“He’ll eventually leave you for someone his own age,” I was warned about my first toyboy boyfriend. But after five lovely months, it was me who called time on our romance.

He had declared his love but I just couldn’t see it lasting. I felt I would
want to start a family at some point
and I wouldn’t want him to give up his carefree days so soon.

I’m sure Harry was never a long-term prospect for Lucy, either. More that she had gone through a difficult time emotionally and welcomed the chance to enjoy the company of a good-looking young guy who was charming and fun.